For me -
The higher the risk, the higher the level of protection
DH certified full face on uplift days , BP Wales , Antur , Alps etc
Open face on bimbles, family trails with Mrs R etc
Finding I use a full face Enduro type helmet a lot more these days
Currently a Met Parachute
I ride a lot in the Forest of Dean where the trails range from easy family trails to off piste Techy Gnar and everything in between
Plenty of places to hurt myself especially as my skillset is not what it was
I usually end up doing some sort of loop to get to the interesting stuff , when I'm there I always feel I made the right choice wearing the Met
To get there I often have to link it up on easy family trails , although I keep this to the minimum, personal choice and years of trail scouting help with this
Even so , I really couldn't give a toss what I look like to all the families pottering about , or to other riders for that matter .
My safety is far more important
Same applies to pads , I always wear elbow and knee /shin pads as well as impact shorts
I find the softer D30 type more comfortable for this type of riding
Did 5 days in North Wales recently , Coed y Brenin, Machynlleth etc
4 were trail centre days and this combo was perfect even though there was plenty of pedalling on very hot days
Did a day uplifting at Antur Stiniog , loads of sharp loose rocks and flint
Swapped my lid for a DH FF
Knee/shin & Elbows for hard shell type, added D30 type back , shoulder and chest protector and felt much more confident letting the brakes go and tackling Gnarlier trails , Bossing it like 'Back in the Day' ? I wish
Same applies to what I now call my Enduro set up which I use on most rides , Met Parachute (well vented full face ) soft elbow , knee/shin pads and impact shorts
If I feel well protected then I get a little more confident, push myself a bit harder and have more of a blast
This is purely my opinion but even so , I don't let others dictate to me what is right / wrong / fashionable or on trend ? I wear what works for me, to be as safe as possible and everyone else can do one ?