with or without mudguards?
- Thread starter Poupy
- Start date
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
Well obviously it looks better without mudguards. 
Your choice is unobtrusive, and I really like that, but I wouldn't call it a mudguard! It is more of a splashguard. If you come across any real mud it will clog very quickly, mud like this for example: (and yes, that is a stick in there!)
I would go for a seat tube mounted mudguard, like this:
MTB MUDGUARDS - 700 MTB Rear Mudguard
It has the great advantage of being not only cheap, but it will fit any diameter seat tube, wheel diameter, or suspension travel. And it absolutely will not clog! Brilliant design, not as unobtrusive as yours, but wayyyyy more effective!
They work and I wouldn't be without one! When I left mine laid on my tow bar rack subsequently to go missing during the drive home, I immediately bought another.
Your choice is unobtrusive, and I really like that, but I wouldn't call it a mudguard! It is more of a splashguard. If you come across any real mud it will clog very quickly, mud like this for example: (and yes, that is a stick in there!)
I would go for a seat tube mounted mudguard, like this:
MTB MUDGUARDS - 700 MTB Rear Mudguard
It has the great advantage of being not only cheap, but it will fit any diameter seat tube, wheel diameter, or suspension travel. And it absolutely will not clog! Brilliant design, not as unobtrusive as yours, but wayyyyy more effective!
They work and I wouldn't be without one! When I left mine laid on my tow bar rack subsequently to go missing during the drive home, I immediately bought another.
- Thread starter
- #3
It is true that from your point of view this yours, after I live in the south of france it rains about 20 days a year and I never ride in as much mud as you
It’s especially level look,
I always put mudguards at the front but at the back c is the first time
It’s especially level look,
I always put mudguards at the front but at the back c is the first time
Without.
To be honest those two mud guards will do next to nothing apart from maybe rub the paint off your frame. As much as I dislike the look of mud guards its all out or don't bother.
I've got an RRP Proguard bolt on and I rate that on the front but don't bother with anything on the rear.
To be honest those two mud guards will do next to nothing apart from maybe rub the paint off your frame. As much as I dislike the look of mud guards its all out or don't bother.
I've got an RRP Proguard bolt on and I rate that on the front but don't bother with anything on the rear.
billwarwick
E*POWAH Elite
Last week, when I removed the hideous but essential for the last few months, mudguards I was overjoyed. My bike looks right now. How can the terrain go from slopfest to hard as concrete in such a short time? Watch out for the ruts?
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
[QUOTE="Poupy, post: 154154, member: 8617"...........I always put mudguards at the front but at the back c is the first time[/QUOTE]
I always fit a front mudguard like yours and I never take it off until I sell the bike. I tried fitting one on the back like you did. It looked nice but was too close to the tyre to be of use.
I always fit a front mudguard like yours and I never take it off until I sell the bike. I tried fitting one on the back like you did. It looked nice but was too close to the tyre to be of use.
That company does not make a mudguard for Rockshox unfortunately.
Fatbap
Well-known member
I fitted 1 front an rear, I have always run a small 1 in the front an it has always worked well enough for me so I thought I’d try a rear 1 but to be honest it does not stop anything. I don’t mind the look so have left it there for now
RE the RRP bolt on. I like that idea, but could not find where I was going to bolt anything to my RS Yari fork. Can you enlighten me about how they bolt on?
As for the mudguards doing little,
I agree they do little in their current position. I actually took a bigger mud guard made for the saddle and lowered it. I wanted to protect my pivots from all the mud that was getting shot up in there. I know the pivot bearing/bushings can probably handle it, it took me a long time to get that mud and dirt out of there.
TransAmMan
Active member
I have one installed BUT its not for MUD .. even though its a mudguard
Its not for looks either but rather to keep ROCKS from jamming in the pivot area (arch) behind the chainstay bridge. Giant Maestro suspension is quite similar where a rock can get trapped in that area and cause a lot of damage. If it was an aluminum swingarm ... not as bad .. but carbon is another story. Not saying it will happen without a mudguard ... but I have seen it before.
I used a modified mudhugger guard that extends down past the chainstay bridge ... but it needed quite a bit of "custom modification" (aka a hack mechanic hitting it with a heat gun)
And Steve above .. WOW !! where the heck are you riding - LOL! Now THAT is MUD !
Its not for looks either but rather to keep ROCKS from jamming in the pivot area (arch) behind the chainstay bridge. Giant Maestro suspension is quite similar where a rock can get trapped in that area and cause a lot of damage. If it was an aluminum swingarm ... not as bad .. but carbon is another story. Not saying it will happen without a mudguard ... but I have seen it before.
I used a modified mudhugger guard that extends down past the chainstay bridge ... but it needed quite a bit of "custom modification" (aka a hack mechanic hitting it with a heat gun)
And Steve above .. WOW !! where the heck are you riding - LOL! Now THAT is MUD !
Last edited:
I fitted a near a identical mud guard to you on my rear and it did pretty much nothing except rub my paint, I did notice that Mucky Nutz have this:
Ahh they don't currently fit Rockshox because there are no threaded holes on the fork brace, my bad. You could drill and tap a thread if you're feeling brave or just order the non bolt on version.
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
.........
And Steve above .. WOW !! where the heck are you riding - LOL! Now THAT is MUD !
That my friend is clay mud mixed in with fallen vegetation, at least one stick, and whatever else gets churned up in the mud. It was taken in May'19 when I thought that "surely by now the trail will be dry?" It wasn't! (it was a wet year last year). It was on the Viking Way near Bevoir Castle in Lincolnshire, England.
When I was out yesterday en-route to where I took that photo, still on the Viking Way, I came across a section of now dry(ish) trail that would have been impassable a week ago. It is now deeply rutted and tricky to ride. I did have to get off an push in a few places. It extends to the end of the pic and round to the right and then round to the left. I thought it would never end.
That rut that is one third in and down from top left is about four feet deep (1.2m). The tractor that made that must have been huge!
There was worse ruts before that, but I was concentrating too hard to think to stop and take a pic. It will be a while before I go again, especially after last nights rain that will have activated the sludge!
RRP Proguard (long and short) fits all rockshox forks.
You need the standard model which fits with zipties.
If you don't like the idea of zipties a CRUD XL fits with o rings and foam to help protect the fork lowers.
I reviewed both guards in depth on the front page of the site. You can read them both from this link.
Gary, Author at EMTB Forums
You need the standard model which fits with zipties.
If you don't like the idea of zipties a CRUD XL fits with o rings and foam to help protect the fork lowers.
I reviewed both guards in depth on the front page of the site. You can read them both from this link.
Gary, Author at EMTB Forums
Last edited:
Fatbap
Well-known member
Thanks mate I’ll have a look. My intention is only to stop some of the shit at the linkage area I was gonna try 2 of them an make a longer 1. I just used rubber tape on the key areas to stop the rubbing an so far so good
Dmitry Raccoon
Member
With!
Dmitry Raccoon
Member
RockShox Super Deluxe Coil Ultimate RCT. I have Decoy Custom, changed shock, brakes, rotors, transmission, bars, stem and gonna change fork damper cartridge.
Seat tube mounted rear guards are incompatible with a dropper post.Well obviously it looks better without mudguards.
Your choice is unobtrusive, and I really like that, but I wouldn't call it a mudguard! It is more of a splashguard. If you come across any real mud it will clog very quickly, mud like this for example: (and yes, that is a stick in there!)
View attachment 28313
I would go for a seat tube mounted mudguard, like this:
MTB MUDGUARDS - 700 MTB Rear Mudguard
It has the great advantage of being not only cheap, but it will fit any diameter seat tube, wheel diameter, or suspension travel. And it absolutely will not clog! Brilliant design, not as unobtrusive as yours, but wayyyyy more effective!
They work and I wouldn't be without one! When I left mine laid on my tow bar rack subsequently to go missing during the drive home, I immediately bought another.
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
Unless the part of the dropper post that slides into the seat tube has sufficient length exposed to clamp on to.
How else do you think I did it?
Unless the part of the dropper post that slides into the seat tube has sufficient length exposed to clamp on to.
How else do you think I did it?
Tried that; I have too much suspension travel to mount the mudguard that low. You must have less suspension travel, a very high saddle position, a steeply angled mudguard, or a combination.Unless the part of the dropper post that slides into the seat tube has sufficient length exposed to clamp on to.
How else do you think I did it?
RickBullotta
E*POWAH Elite World Champion
Never a rear mudguard. Always a front one. I use a Mucky Nutz trimmed back close to the front of the fork crown. A rear mudguard is ultimately just going to create a giant jam up spot.
For rain, same thing. Just front. I don't give a sh*t if my back gets wet. It's gonna anyway.
For rain, same thing. Just front. I don't give a sh*t if my back gets wet. It's gonna anyway.
To tell you the truth I’m a fan of shot with the mudguard, it’s discreet and I like that, would I be right in saying it’s a front mudguard mate.
I've been running this dinky one in the back for a while mainly to stop the build up of crap than protect my back, that's what decent riding gear is for. Smallest cheapest one I could find. Had to clearance the chain side.
Thats with the original 2.8, now only switching between 2.5 or 2.6's in the back, so even more room.
Thats with the original 2.8, now only switching between 2.5 or 2.6's in the back, so even more room.
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
I have 150mm travel. The mudguard is positioned to avoid the tyre when the suspension is used, if I don't, the tyre moves it for me!
I don't understand the point about a very high saddle position. It's at the top of the dropper (!) and set as high as my legs will allow for comfy and efficient pedalling! It can't be any higher. Or maybe you normally have yours lower?
Edit: I could clamp the mudguard around the seat tube of course, ans there is sufficient adjustment in the blade mounting to allow for that, but I prefer the body of the dropper.
Last edited:
I did something very similar to my Decoy. It changed my post-ride clean up from 30 min to 5 minutes. Getting all that crud that gets flung into the linkage was a pain.
I guess if you don't like a rear mud guard, you like to clean.
Mikehocksbig
New Member
For those wondering what a bolt on one is like
EMTB Forums
Latest articles
-
Bosch-powered Merida is here – the eOne-Sixty SL and eOne-Eighty intro and test
Merida has used Bosch-motors for years, but not on the emtbs. The full...- Knut Nes
- 10 min read
- Views: 4K
- Reaction score: 5
- Comments: 9
-
Bosch ABS Pro and Trail Pro - an interview about the new ABS profiles
When testing the new Bosch Performance CX gen5, we were also introduced...- Knut Nes
- 2 min read
- Views: 6K
- Reaction score: 2
- Comments: 5