What was the verdict? I’m looking at Airfit vs Troy lee atm, can’t decide!
saw these too
Ultimately .. it all comes down to compromises and deciding what protection you want in exchange for potentially being warmer or more restricted.
Just to cover your extra two options. I almost bought the dianese, but read so many reviews in the end about poor assembly, bad fit and things not staying in place in accidents, I didn't bother.
I didn't buy the Race Face either as a friend I ride with regularly, has one. He likes it. In summer he just wears it as it is, he rides hard and never has any problems with it. For me, I think the back protector is a bit small - but it's limited to that size or the D3O pad in that style would be too hot and heavy.
So, your compromises

.. The Troy Lee 7855 is really one of a kind. It offers good protection to a large part of the upper body. The twin density foam is surprisingly effective and for me, I've found the elbows to be good too. I think these may have been improved over time. It's also light, lighter than pretty much anything else out there. A medium weighs in at 700g. It also breaths well. All the armour pieces are vented and there's gaps inbetween. It's reasonably easy to get on and off like a sweater, a little harder when it's hot and sweaty, but no impossible act. If it's hot, just wear it as it is and you don't overheat. It's downfall is that whilst it gives good protection almost everywhere, it doesn't give Excellent protection anywhere. The chest is better than an Alpinestars Paragon Pro (which is claimed CE1 but no way is) and as mentioned the elbows seem pretty good and stay in place well in falls. The shoulders are ok for slight glances, but won't give you great protection in a big hit. A lot of the armour panels are removable and my shoulders I've swapped out for chunkier ones. Other upgrades are harder as you'd need to start cutting and sewing. The back is several armour panels, so no full back support. The bottom section of the shirt isn't armoured so the lower back/coccyx isn't well protected (to use the same item as an example - it comes down as far as a paragon pro). It's stretchy, so if you're not sure on sizes - size down.
If you decide you want more focused big crash protection rather then general all over tumble protection then the choices get harder. Ultimately, once you move to higher protection on the back/shoulders and so on, it gets heavier and hotter - so invariably, you can't armour all the other places like the 7855 as you'd be too hot and it would weigh 5kg's !
My favourite general armour at the moment is the Racer Motion Top 2. This has the latest CE1 D3O BP4 back protector which is larger, lighter and better vented than previous versions. The shoulders are great and the whole thing is really nicely thought out and put together. It's really well vented and comfortable to wear even when it's really hot.
Product name: Racer Motion Top 2 Price paid: €200 Score (out of 10): 8 Racers (Racer Gloves) second version of their "Motion Top" with lots of improvements. There are dozens of different "body armours" out there. They all pick their own line through the different compromises you have to make...
www.emtbforums.com
If you want more protection, like a more substantial chest pad for instance, then the Airfit Light is a good option as it's not too hot, heavy or restrictive.
For "Best" protection for back/shoulders/elbows/chest. I think at the moment the Forcefield Pro Shirt xv is probably the way to go. Still testing and haven't had time to write a review yet. Available as a CE1 or CE2. The CE2 has CE2 shoulders, elbows, back chest. For most people I think the CE1 would be sufficient. The armour slowly moulds to your body with heat, so far, it doesn't feel too hot - though I can't heat test anymore as my heat test 32-26 degree window has gone ... It's also light. The CE2 version, with more armour coverage to chest/back/shoulders/elbows, weighs the same as a CE1 Airfit Light. They also do it in an "air" version - which is all mesh rather than semi vented fabric, or without elbows. It doesn't have any abrasion protection, like the troy lee elbows, so not sure how it would handle being torn up. It's also
really stretchy.. I'm generally a Medium in body armours and sometimes a Large. I'm a Small in this and think if they made one, I could stretch an XS over me.
Just a couple of quick pictures .. D3O BP4 Back in
Medium on the left . Force field CE2
Small on the right (the FF CE2 is lighter than the D3O CE1) :
D3O CE1 shoulders and elbows left . Forcefield CE2 right
Most pictures make the Forcefield chest armour look like a large slab of concrete, but it forms around your body. This is after a ride where it's already started to return to flat, but you can see it's curved.
The CE2 armour is quite thick (chest/back about 22mm - the same as D3O CE2) - so if you want to be stealth armoured - you won't be in the forcefield unless you have a jacket over it - another compromise !