Today I finally got to test ride the Gen4.
I drew some interesting conclusions for myself. My main concern was the increased weight, but in reality, it turned out to be no issue at all — even when lifting the bike by hand it was hard to tell the difference from the Gen3. I tested the Expert model.
I’ve been riding a Gen3 for 2 years now, so here are my comparison notes:
Pros:
+ Removable battery – really well implemented and very convenient.
+ Extra weight is not noticeable at all on descents. (its weird to be as a plus but considering it results in "stronger" components i think it is plus thats having that its not noticeable)
+ More powerful motor.
+ While I couldn’t fully confirm this during the test, in the long term it seems useful to have so many adjustment options on the bike, including the Genie shock.
Cons:
- The motor noise is very annoying, the pitch is higher than on the Gen3 and it’s louder too. It reminded me somewhat of the first generation levo SL sound.
- The motor rattles on descents, similar to the Bosch Gen4.
- Even with the shuttle mode set to zero, the motor “pushes” while in turbo. It feels like the software tuning is unbalanced; the power delivery on the Gen3 is much smoother while being 100/100. Once again, it really reminded me of the Bosch Gen4 motor.
- No physical button on the TCU. If for any reason the wired handlebar remote fails, you’re screwed — the bike cannot be turned on in any way whatsoever. At that point it’s just a 24 kg pedal bike with some motor drag. UPD: there is solution for that
- Aesthetically I don’t like it. The oversized downtube is a problem for me since we(riding group) use roof racks, and finding a rack that fits such a wide tube will likely be impossible.
Overall impression:
My experience with the Gen4 was negative. To me, the only real and valuable improvement is the removable battery, which is indeed practical. Everything else feels better on the Gen3. I even grabbed a rental Gen3 Alloy model from the test area (the lowest spec with an RS Deluxe shock) to compare with the Gen4 side by side as they were both test bikes, and the result was basically the same. I didn’t feel any next-level improvement on the descents, while the Gen3 motor’s power delivery was much more pleasant, and the lack of rattling on descents made the bike much nicer to ride.
I really wanted to like the Gen4 since I love the idea of the easily removable battery, but unfortunately this bike is definitely not for me. I’ll keep looking into the Trek Rail with the Bosch Gen5 motor.