Authorities are waking up...

Could we have a sub forum for hand wringing Americans to cry over their state juntas banning fun so us European libs under no such threat can enjoy bombing around unfettered on our 10,000 watt bikes without their shit spamming the joint to death?
 
⚡ EMTB Pro Go Pro — exclusive discounts & ad-free Peaty's 25% off & more · Ad-free browsing · Pro badge See the deals →
Could we have a sub forum for hand wringing Americans to cry over their state juntas banning fun so us European libs under no such threat can enjoy bombing around unfettered on our 10,000 watt bikes without their shit spamming the joint to death?
Well - Queensland in australia are basically banning everything* over 25kmph from july 1st.
Massive fines including sieze and crush.
Expected to roll out to more states.

Kids parents will be fined if under 16.
 
Well - Queensland in australia are basically banning everything* over 25kmph from july 1st.
Massive fines including sieze and crush.
Expected to roll out to more states.
That's been the law in NSW since the day dot. Enforcement has always been the issue.

Once again. The problem is shady retailers selling +25kph E-Motos, under the guise that they will only be used on private land. I literally have mates asking me about them, wanting to use them as commuters.

I have to explain it to them, that the fines are massive, and you get points against your drivers license, meaning you can lose you drivers license. That's why the biggest problem is kids. They have nothing to lose.

I'm pointing these guys towards EMTBs, like the Amflow and Meridas. This is what we need to do. Not start EMTB flame wars like the numpty that's running around this forum, doing exactly that. It's so destructive trying to tie EMTBs to the story in the OP. As I showed. That story has nothing to do with EMTBs.
 
Ok, so DJI Avinox system is not classified as an e-bike in CA, but as a motorcycle? How does this affect DJI, shops selling DJI bikes, etc? Seems like they are now in a different legal class than ebike? Is it the 'nominal' motor power loophole? That is how all the non-legal ebikes get sold at retail, the makers always say 'nominal' power is 750 watts, but the motor is capable of like 3000 or 5000 watts. That's like, every other ebike sold in CA. The nominal thing should probably be rescinded. It's either 750 or less, or it's not.
The S-Works Levo should be banned according to your logic as it has been updated to 850W !?!
 
There kinda laws are kinda stupid, here bikes are already restricted to slow 25km/h 15miles/h and the more powerfull e-mtb people roaming in the forest are absolutely not a problem at all. I think they are trying to target these e-moto types but it might hit a wrong target with it.
 
That's been the law in NSW since the day dot. Enforcement has always been the issue.
Same as in the UK where the issue is also enforcement.

Think enforcement is increasing in some parts of the UK. Recently read about some non-compliant eBikes being confiscated on the spot by the police and crushed.
 
Last edited:
Same as in the UK where the issue is also enforcement.

Think enforcement is increasing in some parts of the UK. Recently read about some non-compliant eBikes being confiscated on the spot by the police and crushed.
Yes, not too many EMTB's in this lot thankfully!
Police seize dozens of illegal electric two-wheelers in major Oxford crackdown
b38bf8de3e474eb9d4930c03d06b333a.webp
 
I ride in a State Preserve next to my house. It has about 15 miles of single track. Up until a few weeks ago “no peddle assist” bikes were allowed (although it was never enforced). Now they just put up signs saying E-Bikes are allowed providing you have a disability that requires it. That is basically throwing in the towel 👍. Everybody has a disability of some kind 😄
 
I ride in a State Preserve next to my house. It has about 15 miles of single track. Up until a few weeks ago “no peddle assist” bikes were allowed (although it was never enforced). Now they just put up signs saying E-Bikes are allowed providing you have a disability that requires it. That is basically throwing in the towel 👍. Everybody has a disability of some kind 😄
Undeniable win when HIPAA protects Americans’ personal health information. You can’t be even asked for proof of a disability. At least that’s my layman’s understanding of the law.
 
Undeniable win when HIPAA protects Americans’ personal health information. You can’t be even asked for proof of a disability. At least that’s my layman’s understanding of the law.
My wife and daughter are in the medical field so I understand HIPAA more than I care to. This is why I feel the authorities are basically throwing in the towel because they know they can’t go down that road. It’s a multiuser trail (hikers/horses/MTB and now EMTB) Everyone that rides these trails knows most of the hikers hate us, so this rule change basically allows the authorities to wash their hand of it which is fine with me. They made a rule that can’t be enforced 👍
 
I've never seen anything like the furore that Avinox has caused in my entire career on the internet. And I used to post on PistonHeads.
 
Seems that there's increased UK wide enforcement of current pedelec laws.

"UK police and local authorities are systematically seizing and crushing illegal and antisocial e-bikes across the country. The crackdown primarily targets bikes that have been modified to exceed the legal 15.5 mph limit, lack necessary registration, or are involved in antisocial behavior, phone snatches, and severe traffic violations."
 
not all emtbs are compliant...
As you can see from the post below from today. Going down your anti-tampering path. There are many Motors where tampering is considered easy. So you are going to get every EMTB outlawed in the UK.

You are not helping. You need to let this go.
I have a 2023 Orbea Rise M10 with ep801, decided to de tune the motor now that it’s out of warranty. I heard a lot of good reviews about **** so went with that. The process was very easy with the Shimano pce-2 device.
 
As you can see from the post below from today. Going down your anti-tampering path. There are many Motors where tampering is considered easy. So you are going to get every EMTB outlawed in the UK.

You are not helping. You need to let this go.
the Rise is RS tuned to 60Nm - the 'detuning' is probably going to the standard Shimano EP801 torque @ 85nm
 
As you can see from the post below from today. Going down your anti-tampering path. There are many Motors where tampering is considered easy. So you are going to get every EMTB outlawed in the UK.


I know many people with Bosch and Shimano motors - the very first thing absolutely every single one of them did was take it to the other shop up the road that allowed the 'chipping' to remove the limiter!

Funny that init
 
the Rise is RS tuned to 60Nm - the 'detuning' is probably going to the standard Shimano EP801 torque @ 85nm
I starred out ***** the tool he used. It's the exact same tool for tampering. The screen to change the torque, has the region control as well.

Point is. I'm not the only person who says the process is very easy.

Making the case that ease of tampering is equivalent to the OP linked News Story of Throttle Driven E-Motos, will get all ebikes banned, including EMTBs. But that does seem the case that the OP is trying to make.

With UK riding access laws so easily swayed. Support him in the UK at your own peril.
 
I know many people with Bosch and Shimano motors - the very first thing absolutely every single one of them did was take it to the other shop up the road that allowed the 'chipping' to remove the limiter!
I''m no expert on Shimano motors but delimiting Bosch Smart System motors is certainly not easy. The chip de-restrictors are expensive and not 100% effective and if you can find anyone to change the firmware to a USA version it still has a max of only 32 kmh, also either method will certainly void any warranty on a new bike!
 
Eh? Swayed how & by whom?
I don't know. It's the raft of UK riders on this forum saying they are trying to protect access rights from, "The Waking Authorities", by starting threads like this one. It seems a UK based theory. We certainly aren't seeing any mention of EMTB issues here in Australia. Only E-Moto.
 
I don't know. It's the raft of UK riders on this forum saying they are trying protect access rights from, "The Waking Authorities", by starting threads like this one. It seems a UK based theory. We certainly aren't seeing any mention of EMTB issues here in Australia. Only E-Moto.
Oh I see. So it's a confident assertion that upon scrutiny turns out to be you citing a guy living in Italy & referring to developments in Italy, extrapolated to the UK without any evidence at all, save for a bunch of randoms on an internet forum & run up to an entire raft of policy. Some might call that overreach. I'd probably choose a different adjective.

With UK riding access laws so easily swayed. Support him in the UK at your own peril.

Hmmm.
 
If you check the person I quoted. They have said this.

Just concerned that knee jerk legislation is going to react to high powered motors - my bike is limited from 85 to 60Nm but it still draws 339W in turbo - exceeding 250W - don't want to be told I can only ride with permission on private land or other stupidness like licensing.
After 20 mins at full power, the Bosch CX5 continues to deliver over 600 watts. The Shimano EP801, over 450 watts. The Avinox M1 over 800 watts.

Tying these legal motors to illegal E-Moto news stories in Social Media posts gets picked up by AI search bots, and forwarded as answers to questions people ask search engines. Then suddenly mistruths become truths, and authorities do step in.
 
If you check the person I quoted. They have said this.
I'm sure they did & you're just the piano player. Unfortunately, the tune you ended up playing bears no relation to what was composed or indeed objective reality. It would be easier all round if you just for once attempted to overcome your programming & accept that His majesty's government is not in fact reviewing countryside trail accessibility just because some guy said so on here & it gave your own biases one hell of a cuddle. I'm not much of a fan of out & out bullshit, doubling down on it, even less so.

With UK riding access laws so easily swayed. Support him in the UK at your own peril.
Hmmm.
 
According the Google AI Amflow bikes are illegal in California and some other states as they have a power of more than 750W.

The First Bike Tester (also not an influencer) is running a campaign to get one particular brand of motor banned wherever he can. Others are joining his crusade.
 
Unfortunately, the tune you ended up playing bears no relation to what was composed or indeed objective reality.
Sure. Sometimes in risk management, you present a solution to a risk that has almost zero probability of happening, just to cover off anyone going down that path.
 
According the Google AI Amflow bikes are illegal in California and some other states as they have a power of more than 750W.
I think this is actually correct, because Cali law quotes maximum motor power, not rated motor power. You are supposed to manually set peak power to 750watts to comply. Specialized has the same issue.
 
Keep reading
    Browse all

    Similar Threads

    Community Stats

    Since 2018
    669K
    Messages
    40,995
    Members
    Join 30,000+ Riders, it's free!
    Back
    Top