It's not unheard of for lighter Enduro riders to run a lighter fork. Last year Nico Vouilloz swapped back to a Lyrik from a Zeb on his Emtb for EWS racing.
Pinkbike asked him about it in a recent bikecheck article (He's on the new Zeb now):
" So the Lyrik was for harshness more than weight?
NV - The Lyrik was not for the weight it was just less physical to ride. It was not for the 200 g. In some sections, you can really feel the benefit of the bigger fork like if it's more downhill bike terrain. But when it's slow speed with the stiffness sometimes it's harder to ride, you maybe do more mistakes. But I have the feeling that with the Buttercups, the new air side, less friction and the hydraulic, the stiffness of the fork is less of an issue.
So you said it was the slow-speed stuff where you noticed the downside of the old Zeb (compared to the Lyrik). That surprises me because I thought it would be the fast, high-frequency stuff where the Zeb might feel harsher.
NV - A Lyrik when it's a slow track, really tight and slow, maybe it's a bit better because it's more flexy when there's no speed. As soon as you carry speed, the Zeb is better because it's stiffer, and more stable, it makes you feel more planted when you carry speed. The flex of the Lyrik helps a bit on slow rooty things. Grip on roots. You lose a bit when it's fast
"
Full article here:
Old Code calipers with Guide RSC levers, a modified cassette - Nico's setups are always worth a closer look.
www.pinkbike.com
@Renton
From what you've said it doesn't sound like anything was wrong with the Lyrik or 36 you had. and there's nothing wrong with running compression almost open so long as you're still happy with performance and support is still there. it's just personal pref. I run all my forkks with very little compression damping too.
Unless you're really heavy, ride a lot of DH or an absolute pinner you may not benefit from a bigger fork upfront. And if you do then it begs the question. Why on earth are you riding a Levo? ie. fairly average trail bike rather than something far more suitable
To me, a 35/36mm stnchion fork would seem a better match for a Levo than a Zeb or 38. But don't let my view influence you.