Just an update on my issue from above.
Just as this post says my issue was the pressure between both air chambers was not equalizing (probably due to excess grease clogging it up completely).
After deflating down to lower PSI's I noticed I was losing a huge amount of the fork travel and even up at 50-60 PSI the fork was at a minimum of 20% sag with all weight removed from the fork.
I was able to get the forks air chambers equalized by letting out all the air from the fork then inserting a zip tie in through the seals to release air from the lower legs. With the zip ties still in I pumped the forks up to the recommended PSI for my weight. I cycled the fork a few times then removed the zip ties. At this point the forks full travel was available and its performing much closer to how I expected it to run.
@Mikerb I'm guessing there will still be excess grease where the air chambers join and this will likely have a performance impact on how the fork works or just on setting it up?