Suggestions for replacement shock on 2023 scott eride ransom for heavy rider

[Rocketb]

This bike came with a performance x2 (comp/rebound) in scott tune.
It started leaking air then the dreaded x2 squelch came.
Fox Australia replaced for a 2024 factory x2.
This lasted 9 days with oil leaking on the reservoir.
Replaced last week with another 2024 factory x2.
I’m running 298psi and two air spacers, feels terrible.
I contacted fox last week and they agreed to replace with a factory float x (350psi).

This bike has 180mm of travel and I do flow/dh and trail Knar type of riding so not sure if this shock will hold up!

I haven’t used a coil before (would need a 708 or larger spring) but open to what works.

Any suggestions?

 

[Paulquattro]

Hi
Before you get into coils
Make sure the leverage ratio on the rear suspension is high enough if your jumping etc

 

[Rocketb]

Hi
Before you get into coils
Make sure the leverage ratio on the rear suspension is high enough if your jumping etc

Yeah I thought this might be an issue. The Öhlins distributer recommended a coil over air but said it would come down to preference

 

[Paulquattro]

Yeah I thought this might be an issue. The Öhlins distributer recommended a coil over air but said it would come down to preference

I fell into this with my trek rail
Loads running coils but for me the suspension wasn't progressive enough so ended up with an ohlins air can

 

[Rocketb]

I fell into this with my trek rail
Loads running coils but for me the suspension wasn't progressive enough so ended up with an ohlins air can

How do you find the shock? I was seriously considering this one.

 

[Paulquattro]

How do you find the shock? I was seriously considering this one.

Brilliant
I had it tuned for the Rail when i bought it and its been faultless
Easy to add and remove tokens too which is good if you like a bit of tuning yourself .

 

[Tubby G]

Surely the new Vivid has to be a contender:

Review: RockShox Vivid - Shock Week 2023 - Pinkbike

Shiny and new, the RockShox Vivid is the freshest shock in this week's lineup.

www.pinkbike.com

 

[Paulquattro]

Surely the new Vivid has to be a contender:

Review: RockShox Vivid - Shock Week 2023 - Pinkbike

Shiny and new, the RockShox Vivid is the freshest shock in this week's lineup.

www.pinkbike.com

Good looking shock

 

[Rocketb]

Brilliant
I had it tuned for the Rail when i bought it and its been faultless
Easy to add and remove tokens too which is good if you like a bit of tuning yourself .

View attachment 124907

Looks good.

 

[Rocketb]

Surely the new Vivid has to be a contender:

Review: RockShox Vivid - Shock Week 2023 - Pinkbike

Shiny and new, the RockShox Vivid is the freshest shock in this week's lineup.

www.pinkbike.com

I went through two suspension tuners here and both agreed the shock would be too linear with the larger shaft and air can ie coil like. I agree the shock looks good but my factory x2 was too linear and not progressive enough for my needs.