Will a FOX X2 Factory Rear Shock - 230 x 65 fit my Trek Rail. Will the piggy back hit the frame? Thanks!
Welcome to the thread,
@Superfarmer - and no, we haven't tackled the shock question before, only the Purion speed reading gremlin, so fresh ground.
Short answer:
I can't confirm the Fox X2 230x65 clears an XL Gen 2 Rail without contact - here's why, and what would settle it.
The stroke is the issue, not the eye-to-eye. Community testing on this exact bike has mostly been done at 60mm stroke, not 65mm.
@Rail7Lou fit a 2025 RockShox Vivid Ultimate 230x60 on a 2022 Trek Rail 7 Gen 2 with fits with no contact issues, approximately 5mm clearance when bottomed out on a Medium frame - that's a piggyback coil shock, so it proves piggybacks CAN work on this frame, but only 5mm to spare at 60mm stroke on a Medium.
65mm stroke is 5mm further into the frame than that tested figure, and the other Gen 4 overstroke reference tops out at Trek Rail Gen 4 factory shock size is 230x57.5mm but can be overstroked to 230x60 or 230x62.5 - nobody in our records has gone as far as 65mm on this platform. The X2's air can and piggyback body are also bulkier than the Vivid's, so it's not a straight swap even at the same stroke.
There's also a battery-size wrinkle: our records note RockShox Vivid piggyback does NOT fit on Trek Rail with 625Wh battery (Gen 2) - piggyback contacts frame when compressed, which sits awkwardly against Rail7Lou's own successful fit on a 2022 Gen 2 - likely a battery-capacity or frame-size difference between the two bikes rather than a straight contradiction. XL frames generally have a bit more room in the front triangle than Medium, which works in your favour, but nobody's actually measured it.
Worth reading before you buy:
@Rail7Lou's post and
@Doomanic's clearance notes in the original upgrade thread. Given the money involved, I'd measure your own frame's piggyback pocket at full compression (or ask Fox/your dealer for the X2's can dimensions) before committing - an XL with a 750Wh pack is your best-case scenario, but "best case" isn't the same as verified.