Are you saying that as the positive alternative to "dead" ?? ie, breakfast in bed every day, young nurses giving you a bed bath (some female ones too maybe) ..
Shocked...amazed... disillusioned
- Thread starter taxidriver50005
- Start date
steve_sordy
Wedding Crasher
@taxidriver50005 I really would not worry about the alleged unreliability of emtbs.
Many have said that nobody goes on the internet to say that they haven't had a problem (which is why I just did above!). so it is only full of horror stories. You can't even draw a conclusion by counting up and saying that all the Specialized Levos are crap because they fill with mud and their Brose motors keep failing, until you know how many there are as a proportion of all emtbs. They may be better than most, or worse; I sure don't know. What I can say is that I rarely see any posts from people complaining about Specialized's warranty program, but do see complaints about other makes. It's a tricky one; do you want a motor with zero complaints (from a maker with low sales) but crap warranty or a great warranty and lots of motor failure reports (from a maker that sells tens of thousands)?
Then there are the riding conditions. Will you be riding through rivers, deep mud and all through the winter? Thought not.
Then there is the maintenance and after care. Some people treat their bikes like absolute shit and they don't care because that is what the warranty program is for. They have a different set of values to others, but still complain when the bike goes wrong. Many others treat their bikes like the valuable plaything it is. They clean it properly after a mucky ride and lube and service it as required. Like me.
My final point is the rider. @Gary above is an ex DH racer, he is a lot younger than me and he gives his bikes a seriously hard time because as an expert rider he can do so. I am an old git with ambitions to be a better rider, but with a heightened sense of self preservation because I don't heal as quick as I used to. So, as he so artfully described, my miles are NOTHING like his. But my miles may be more like yours. I didn't even start riding an mtb (let alone an emtb) until I was already older than you are now. So don't worry, just buy the bike that appeals to you, have fun.
PS: I do not own a Specialized emtb or Speccy ordinary bike for that matter and never have.
Many have said that nobody goes on the internet to say that they haven't had a problem (which is why I just did above!). so it is only full of horror stories. You can't even draw a conclusion by counting up and saying that all the Specialized Levos are crap because they fill with mud and their Brose motors keep failing, until you know how many there are as a proportion of all emtbs. They may be better than most, or worse; I sure don't know. What I can say is that I rarely see any posts from people complaining about Specialized's warranty program, but do see complaints about other makes. It's a tricky one; do you want a motor with zero complaints (from a maker with low sales) but crap warranty or a great warranty and lots of motor failure reports (from a maker that sells tens of thousands)?
Then there are the riding conditions. Will you be riding through rivers, deep mud and all through the winter? Thought not.
Then there is the maintenance and after care. Some people treat their bikes like absolute shit and they don't care because that is what the warranty program is for. They have a different set of values to others, but still complain when the bike goes wrong. Many others treat their bikes like the valuable plaything it is. They clean it properly after a mucky ride and lube and service it as required. Like me.
My final point is the rider. @Gary above is an ex DH racer, he is a lot younger than me and he gives his bikes a seriously hard time because as an expert rider he can do so. I am an old git with ambitions to be a better rider, but with a heightened sense of self preservation because I don't heal as quick as I used to. So, as he so artfully described, my miles are NOTHING like his. But my miles may be more like yours. I didn't even start riding an mtb (let alone an emtb) until I was already older than you are now. So don't worry, just buy the bike that appeals to you, have fun.
PS: I do not own a Specialized emtb or Speccy ordinary bike for that matter and never have.
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #33
I was going to buy 2 Bosch engined bikes, like I said new to this and don't need a bike that I can only access 25% of its abilities bragging rights don't really concern me. I do want reliability, I'm always busy and when I'm not I do t want to be fixing a bike when I should be out riding
Sorry mate but what are you even talking about now?
No.
The odds are. You DEFINITELY WILL. it's just a matter of when.
if you intend on keeping it and riding it for ever.
No current Ebike motor is truely reliable for agressive off road use long term.
But now you know this. Why worry?
Do you want the e8000 rattle or the e7000 rattle ? As the mighty destructacon, I think he has both ..
E8000 please
Ah, but if he's not even going to use 25% of the bikes abilities, then he's 400% less likely to ever have a problem
This is my E7000 that shat it's pants at 700 (road) miles
Got rid of the entire bike, EHardtails are shit (too heavy to be fun like a normal hardtail and the E7000 IMO is just not up to the job I want done
This is my first E8000 with the bearings gone
I've actually lost count what motor replacement I'm at now
Hmm ? maybe that isn't what's wrong with mine as it doesn't do anything like that, it rattles really badly over rough ground, it did sound like it was coming from the motor though...
Normal pedalling is fine so not the bearings then I guess.
More investigation necessary...
Normal pedalling is fine so not the bearings then I guess.
More investigation necessary...
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #43
Your right car companies don't disclose this info BUT car magazines do..JD POWER ECT. WHICH CAR DOES AS do many other...its always best to make an informed decision .
Not every rider wants or needs the latest brightest bike that will improve your lap time by 20% over last year's bike, some of us mere mortals don't possess the skils required for a new bike every time the warranty is expiring and would like to keep hold of what we have
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #45
You mentioned there are no capable Yamaha engined bikes.......im sure what there is out there will be able to do more than I can , I don't need a Levo stunt jumper to prove my balls are bigger than any one else. F### me this is like a Apple forum...my phone is better than yours or I have more money than you
What phone and how much money you have?
... jkMan, this is 2020, nearly every product what you buy nowadays are created to maximise profit for the company and share holders. The apparent quality of the products stay the same or increase from year to year, but the reality is, you get less reliability, or usable time without servicing each year. This is not an E-bike specific problem, but I think you already know that.
I know it's frustrating to see the world run like that, but you have to accept it, because you can't change things. Buy something you like, you will get warranty, and ride as much as you can in the nature,that will make you forget a bit how f***d up our world is.
Seriously?
Make your mind up, are you really SHOCKED, AMAZED and DISILUSIONED?
or would you be perfectly happy with a sub £1000 hub motor ebike from Decathlon or Halfords for the next ten years or however long you expect a bike to last with lubing the chain being the only maintenance you're willing to do?
No one has even mentioned what bike or phone they have nevermind how much money they have.
Well that's been an interesting read
Seems me and the OP have a lot in common, I to am a taxi driver, I too had a scorpa sy250 and I too have alarm bells ringing with what on the face of things seems a lot of issues with these bikes.
On the otherhand, although not got one yet, I'm going n with my eyes wide open knowing that there may be/likely to be issues and that is why I shall be buying local.
To the OP, the fella Gary seems a bit of a know all cock sure of himself but probably does know his shit rather than knowing he's shit just possibly misunderstood in his manner of posting.
btw, I got shot of my scorpa and ended up with everything else after that, other than a monty, gave it up now though.
Seems me and the OP have a lot in common, I to am a taxi driver, I too had a scorpa sy250 and I too have alarm bells ringing with what on the face of things seems a lot of issues with these bikes.
On the otherhand, although not got one yet, I'm going n with my eyes wide open knowing that there may be/likely to be issues and that is why I shall be buying local.
To the OP, the fella Gary seems a bit of a know all cock sure of himself but probably does know his shit rather than knowing he's shit just possibly misunderstood in his manner of posting.
btw, I got shot of my scorpa and ended up with everything else after that, other than a monty, gave it up now though.
MrBrownstone
Well-known member
Shimano E8000. The end.
Mines been brilliant 2000 Kilometres lately.
(conformation bias - seeing lots of failures, due to people posting failures, not the 364 days of the year they didn’t fail ?
Frankieboy
Well-known member
If you want a poll why don’t you create your own? You can do so in questions section. You can phrase the question exactly how you want it, so you will hopefully get the answer you looking for.
If you ride hard and fast you don't notice it because you are breathing really hard and going "WooHoo" a lot. Plus all your friends are doing the same.
I dont ride hard, but I have a wife, so I'm used to the whining.
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #53
As a ambassador for the sport Gary does to this forum what Hitler did for the Nazi party.Well that's been an interesting read
Seems me and the OP have a lot in common, I to am a taxi driver, I too had a scorpa sy250 and I too have alarm bells ringing with what on the face of things seems a lot of issues with these bikes.
On the otherhand, although not got one yet, I'm going n with my eyes wide open knowing that there may be/likely to be issues and that is why I shall be buying local.
To the OP, the fella Gary seems a bit of a know all cock sure of himself but probably does know his shit rather than knowing he's shit just possibly misunderstood in his manner of posting.
btw, I got shot of my scorpa and ended up with everything else after that, other than a monty, gave it up now though.
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #54
To be fair I wouldn't have a clue on how to do it and would leave that to the more technically minded than myself
taxidriver50005
Active member
- Thread starter
- #55
As you don't know me you have no idea of what maintenance I am capable of or willing to do, you also sound a little elitist when mentioning decathlon or halfords, for some this is a perfect fit for there requirements and not somethink to be ashamed of.
RodC
Member
choose a brand that has a good reputable dealer Near you, trust their warranty and start enjoying.
you’re suffering before getting into it. Maybe you shouldstay away from ebikes.
Edit: and I mean this in a good sense, you are worried before owning one... what will happen when you own one? You’ll be thinking about tomorrow’s possible failures and how much $ you spent on the bike.
stay with traditional MTB and don’t add another bitterness into your life.
Last edited:
Frankieboy
Well-known member
Starting a poll doesn’t look too difficult, and, if you‘re not motivated to do it why should others do so on your behalf? The most important part will be in the phrasing of the question, so you get a balanced response. You could have a look at some of the existing polls to get an idea of how that might look.
MitchF
E*POWAH Elite
Wow, just logged on, is this debate still going ?
You could have bought one and put 50mls on it in the time it’s taken to read and write all this ??
You can’t compare trials bikes that have been evolving for many, many decades with e-Bikes that have been evolving a decade, manufacturers are still learning.
your a trials rider so you’ll know that anything used off road needs good maintenance and care. Same with EMTB’s. You’ll also, I’ll assume, enjoy fettling your bike, same with EMTB.
For what it’s worth, I’ve had a Giant/Yam and now have a Cube/Bosch , no serious issues with either of them and both more capable than me. The only costs I’ve incurred are bits I’ve bent or broken on trees or falling off.
as for Gary, just block him then you didn’t have to listen. Big fish in a small pond syndrome.
You could have bought one and put 50mls on it in the time it’s taken to read and write all this ??
You can’t compare trials bikes that have been evolving for many, many decades with e-Bikes that have been evolving a decade, manufacturers are still learning.
your a trials rider so you’ll know that anything used off road needs good maintenance and care. Same with EMTB’s. You’ll also, I’ll assume, enjoy fettling your bike, same with EMTB.
For what it’s worth, I’ve had a Giant/Yam and now have a Cube/Bosch , no serious issues with either of them and both more capable than me. The only costs I’ve incurred are bits I’ve bent or broken on trees or falling off.
as for Gary, just block him then you didn’t have to listen. Big fish in a small pond syndrome.
Chain slap ?
EMTB Forums
Latest articles
-
The new 2025 Orbea Rise - my wish come true?
A few months ago, I wrote an article about a great bike that didn’t...- Knut Nes
- 5 min read
- Views: 10K
- Reaction score: 7
- Comments: 20
-
The lightweight Canyon Neuron:ONfly CF is here!
Finally, Canyon is out with their first mid-assist, lightweight emtb...- Knut Nes
- 6 min read
- Views: 5K
- Reaction score: 5
- Comments: 5