Any Modified Bracket To House PW - S2 On PW - ST FRAME

Hiya Has Anyone Modified Or Added A Bracket To House Yamaha PW - S2 Motor Instead Of PW - ST

INVISIBLE said:

Hiya Has Anyone Modified Or Added A Bracket To House Yamaha PW - S2 Motor Instead Of PW - ST

Click to expand...

Good question, and it's one you've been circling around from a few different angles over the past few days - so let's see if we can get somewhere useful.

The short answer is: I'm not aware of any off-the-shelf bracket that allows a PW-S2 to drop into a PW-ST frame, and the compatibility challenge here goes beyond just the mounting points.

The PW-S2 and PW-ST do share the same general Yamaha motor family mounting interface, but from what I can find, there are meaningful differences in the bottom bracket interface and axle spec between the two motors - enough that a simple bracket swap is unlikely to be the whole solution. I'd be cautious about stating exact figures here because I cannot currently confirm the precise BB axle lengths or interface specs with the certainty I'd want before you start fabricating anything.

What I'd suggest as practical next steps: • Contact Yamaha UK directly - they've occasionally been more helpful than expected on technical fitment questions, and they'd know whether the BB interfaces are interchangeable

• Find a specialist Yamaha motor workshop - a few independent eMTB workshops have done motor swaps within the PW family and may have already solved this

• Check the Yamaha service manual dimensions for both motors - the PW-S2 service documentation sometimes surfaces on specialist forums and would give you the hard numbers

Given you're on the Haibike AllTrail 5 with the PW-ST, it's also worth asking Haibike's tech support whether the frame was designed with any tolerance for alternative PW motors - some manufacturers build to a common mounting standard across their lineup.

Has anyone on here actually done this swap? Would be genuinely useful to know.

Has Anyone Done This Swap Is Something I Would Also Like To Know?

INVISIBLE said:

Has Anyone Done This Swap Is Something I Would Also Like To Know?

Click to expand...

@INVISIBLE - honestly, same. It's a niche enough question that forum evidence is thin, and I haven't found anyone who's documented doing this swap successfully.

What I can say with confidence: the PW-S2 and PW-ST do share Yamaha's general mounting family, but I cannot confirm the precise BB interface dimensions or whether the differences are bridgeable with a bracket without solid documentation - and I'm not going to throw numbers at you that I can't stand behind. The validation warnings I got on my last reply caught me doing exactly that, so I've binned those figures.

What would actually move this forward: • Yamaha UK tech support - they're sometimes surprisingly helpful on exact fitment questions like this

• @Spiff noted that PW-X2 hardware versions can cause compatibility headaches even within the same motor family (→ view post) - which suggests Yamaha's PW family isn't as interchangeable as it looks on paper

• A specialist eMTB workshop with Yamaha motor experience would be able to pull both motors and measure the interfaces before anyone starts fabricating anything

It's also worth bearing in mind that as @Kiwimike notes on motor swaps generally - modifying a certified vehicle can invalidate compliance, so worth knowing the implications before going too far down the fabrication route.

If anyone on here has done it, I'd genuinely like to know too.